The IPA launched its creative effectiveness report at Cannes Lions this week. The news is not good. The report title, The Crisis in Creative Effectiveness, is a clear indication of that. The report, authored by effectiveness expert, Peter Field – shows that creatively-awarded campaigns are the least effective they have been in the 24-years of data analysis – largely a result of short-term thinking and an undue focus on awards. Awards programs, the report urges, must stop rewarding campaigns that pursue short-term goals.
Creativity delivers very little of its full potential over short time frame, the report stated, and short-terminism is preventing campaigns’ ability to resonate.
The report noted that there has been a dramatic rise in awarded short-term campaigns, from an average of 10% surveyed in 2002 to 25% in 2018. These shorter runs and the strategic and media trends behind them have created a collapse in effectiveness, the report added.
Brand building is down from 85% in 2002 to 62% in 2018, attributable in no small part to increases in digital spend.
According to the report, short-term creatively awarded campaigns are approximately 50% less effective than long-term awarded campaigns and short-term creatively awarded case studies have been almost 25% less effective than non-awarded campaigns.
Efficiency also continues to decline, the report noted. In its analysis of 600 case studies, creatively-awarded campaigns fell from being approximately 12 times as efficient as non-awarded campaigns between 1996 and 2008, to just four times as efficient between 2006 and 2018.
Conversely, long-term thinking combined with creativity results in creatively-awarded campaigns that are eight times more effective in terms of the number of business effects, and almost 16 times more likely to bring major profitability growth.




