By Candide McDonald, editor.
When I told the woman at my Coles’ checkout on Friday night that I didn’t want my Little Shop toys and I wished that Coles was not producing them because they were bad for the environment, she replied, “They’re much better quality than last time. They look so real.” On my way to the car park, I passed a mum who was gushing to her child as she unwrapped her mini Vegemite. Note that she was unwrapping it. The little plastic toys that the world doesn’t need in rubbish bins and wherever else they end up after their inevitable abandonment, are also wrapped in more stuff that’s going to clog up the planet.
Clearly, not everyone gets the point of the Coles Change.org petition, which has reached 63,333 signatures in just a few days. And apparently to Coles, profit trumps environmental responsibility resoundingly. If it wasn’t enough to launch Little Shop a month after its removal of single use plastic bags – albeit begrudgingly and by introducing what are meant to be multi-use, but are unlikely to always be, plastic bags for a negligible fee – Coles launched Little Shop during Plastic Free July, a global movement to encourage households to refuse single-use plastics.
And let’s not overlook the fact that brands have to opt in. 30 brands are participating in Little Shop 2. Or that there is a huge advertising campaign supporting Little Shop.
Woolworths has countered Coles’ bid for weekly shop supremacy with its own collectibles, Lion King “Ooshies”. Woolies has predicted the fallout by partnering with recycling company, TerraCycle, to repurpose unwanted Ooshies into plastic pellets for outdoor furniture. (Assuming that customers go to the trouble of taking their abandoned toys back to the store.) The bag the Ooshies come in is also made of FSC material and can be recycled in yellow bins (assuming customers read the fine print).
A similar (but older – 8 months) petition by two German children (or, most likely, their parents), asking McDonald’s and Burger King to remove the plastic toys they hand out in kids’ meals and promotions, has received 402,049 signatures.
McDonald’s has finally taken notice. Last week, the chain began scaling back the volume of hard plastic toys it hands out, it said, and is offering alternatives such as board games, books and soft toys while it assesses “wider public feedback”. We all know that may or may not go well for the planet.
McDonald’s spokesperson stated, “The reduction in the use of plastics is a very important issue to McDonald’s globally and consistent with our overall Scale for Good packaging and recycling goals. We have an active global working group exploring the production of more sustainable toy options.
“While we cannot provide details of our Happy Meal promotions beyond the end of 2019 at this stage, we remain committed to reducing plastic across our business.”
The nonsense that was broadcast in the Australian media last year about the “difficulty” of taking one’s own bags to the supermarket shows that the sustainability message is not getting through clearly enough. It’s a bit hard to tell brands that environmental and social responsibility matters to their bottom line when it matters only to a segment of their customer base. But that doesn’t mean that brands can continue to put profit before the planet, its wildlife or its people. They can become responsible leaders.
As can agencies. The problem is finding the courage and the resolve to do so.
It’s an intriguing problem that won’t be easily solved. Nothing worth fighting for ever is – sadly. The first edition of Coles Little Shop last year contributed to the chain’s sales uplift of 5.8% to $7.66 billion in the relevant financial quarter. Some participating brands recorded increases of up to 50%.
I guess my message is a plea. Creative people are meant to love intriguing problems. Solving this problem – getting brands, people, governments – and advertising and production agencies – to stop making only the sacrifices that suit them for the sake of the planet – must carry a reward better than being given a chunk of metal at the next round of awards, mustn’t it? And who knows, pitch the right idea to the right brand or institution and you might get both rewards.
As an aside, or as inspiration (take your pick):
In January, Kinder was pilloried in social media for making an inadvertent reference to the Ku Klux Klan in its Kinder Surprises. Never mind that it has been filling the world with little plastic toys since 1974.
is this a KKK kinder surprise? @kinderus pic.twitter.com/SJzdZjzVNk
— victor china (@china_victor) December 21, 2018
is this a KKK kinder surprise? @kinderus pic.twitter.com/SJzdZjzVNk
— victor china (@china_victor) December 21, 2018










