In June, the UK’s Advertising Standards Authority introduced new rules about gender stereotyping because, it said, some portrayals could play a part in “limiting people’s potential”. The new rules ban advertising featuring “harmful gender stereotypes” or those that are likely to cause “serious or widespread offence”. They cover broadcast and non-broadcast advertisements, including online and social media.
The first banned ads come from Mondelez brand, Philadelphia, and Volkswagen.
Philadelphia’s commercial shows two men who become distracted in a restaurant and let the baby be carried away on the food conveyor belt. It received 128 complaints because the men were seen to be ineffective childcarers. Mondelez argued that it had chosen the men to avoid the stereotypical scenario of new mums handling all the childcare responsibilities.
Ironically perhaps, The Volkswagen commercial for its eGolf car was banned for depicting women in a stereotypical childcare role. It received just three complaints. It shows two male astronauts in a space ship and a male para-athlete doing the long jump, while a woman is shown sitting on a bench next to a pram.
Volkswagen UK argued that its ad made no suggestion that childcare was solely associated with women, and that showing a woman calmly reading defied the advertising stereotype of a harassed or anxious parent.
The third commercial to be investigated under the new laws was for Nestlé’s water brand, Buxton.
In the spot, three people are shown practising their skills while drinking Buxton water – a female ballerina, a male drummer and a male rower. The commercial received five complaints about showing stereotypical behaviour. Nestlé argued that each person was a high achiever in his or her field and the ads depicted the hard work and perseverance that had gone into developing their skills to an expert level. The ASA agreed.
Clearcast, the non-governmental organisation that pre-approves most British television advertising, passed both of the banned ads. The Philadelphia spot, it stated, showed a momentary lapse in concentration by new parents, not fathers being unable to look after the babies properly because of their gender. it also judged the Volkswagen spot to be balanced, showing both men and women in adventurous activities (in an earlier scene a man and woman are camping on a sheer cliff face) and that the mother with the pram scene was a reasonable stereotype.





